Foreign edu-business corporations, such as Bridge International Academies (BIA), are targeting families in Lagos, Nigeria by setting up fee charging education facilities to expand their business model. For parents looking for a quality school for their children, is this a good option?
Nigeria is just one of the targets of Bridge, whose facilities have been shut down in Kenya and Uganda for violating their national laws. In March, Uganda’s high court determined that Bridge set out to operate illegally, with blatant disregard for minimum standards required by law.
Bridge is one of the largest education for-profit companies in the world, with plans to sell services to 10 million fee-paying students throughout Africa and Asia by 2025. According to new research launched on May 31, in Lagos, Nigeria, by Education International, the Bridge facilities, which use unqualified staff paid at low wages, are not a quality option for the students who attend or for the communities in which they live.
The study: Quality and Equalities: a comparative study of public and low-cost private schools in Lagos, analyses how public and private schools in Lagos deliver on quality and equality, particularly for children from poor households.
More expensive, lower qualifications
According to the research, since the 1980s there has been inadequate state provision for primary schooling in Lagos. A huge private sector has grown with very limited effective regulation. Currently, about 18,000 private schools operate in Lagos, a 50 percent increase since 2011. Furthermore, foreign aid money has supported the expansion of private schools. Notably, in 2014, £3.45 million from UK’s Department for International Development (DFID) was paid to Bridge International Academies, facilitating its entry into Lagos. In other words, government aid designed for development assistance is instead going to controversial private operators.
The research found that among private education providers, Bridge is on average more expensive for parents, uses unqualified staff, has low standards for staff training and is less concerned about inclusiveness and equality than others. By comparison, public schools in Lagos, which are free, have teachers with the highest level of qualification - all have formal teaching qualifications and inservice training.
Full room at research launch: “Quality and Equalities: a comparative study of public and low cost private schools in Lagos”- Nigeria Union of Teachers stands up for public education! #studentsbeforeprofit pic.twitter.com/O7N8SKuBDe— EduInternational (@eduint) May 31, 2018
The researchers also found that despite the limited funding and other challenges faced by public schools, the teachers were dedicated to their students and to the values of equality and inclusiveness.
Invest in public education
Against this backdrop, the Secretary General of the Nigeria Union of Teachers (NUT), Dr. Mike Ike Ene, stated: “Low cost private schools, are not an alternative to public education. If investments are not made in public education the needs of all children will not be met and quality and equality in schooling will be further undermined. We support Education International in conducting this research which also highlights the professionalism and dedication of Nigeria’s public school teachers and their commitment despite the challenges to providing quality education for all”, he added.
“Education is a public good and the right of every child, and therefore its provision should be a fundamental responsibility of government,” stated in a joint release the president of the Nigeria Union of Teachers (NUT) Michael A. Olukoya National President and Dr. Mike Ike Ene, Secretary General of NUT “Any fee, any economic barrier is an obstacle to access to education, particularly for girls and the socially disadvantaged. To date, global progress in education access has only been possible thanks to the public sector expansion and the abolition of fees,” they added.
A message from Nigeria teachers: We consider it inappropriate that international development assistance is going to for-profit operators such as @BridgeIntlAcads rather than working with the government to develop quality in public schools.@DFID_UK stop investing in Bridge! pic.twitter.com/DCwm6vlG7f— EduInternational (@eduint) May 31, 2018
David Edwards, General Secretary of Education International, went on to say: “This is not the first time our research exposes the exploitative practices of this education business chain. From Kenya, to Uganda, to Liberia, we have seen how Bridge facilities are contributing to the deepening of segregation in education. They undermine the right of children to free quality education.“
It is deplorable that the British Government through @DFID_UK is handing over tax payers money intended for international development to a for-profit illegal operator, #BridgeInternationalAcademies #studentsbeforeprofit #unite4ed @cyclingkev pic.twitter.com/epjx7YE0iK— EduInternational (@eduint) May 31, 2018
The report Quality and Equalities: a comparative study of public and low-cost private schools in Lagos by Unterhalter E., Robinson L., & Ibrahim J. (2018) is available here: pdf
The executive summary is available here: pdf.
Five reasons to stop investing in Brdge for-profit academies
The research was conducted by Elaine Unterhalter, Centre for Education and International Development, UCL Institute of Education, Jibrin Ibrahim, Centre for Democracy and Development, Abuja, Nigeria. Research Assistants: Lynsey Robinson Grace Nweke, Department of Special Education, University of Ibadan, Nigeria Olabanke Lawson, UCL Institute of Education Abayomi Awelewa